The Kosher Terroir
We are enjoying incredible global growth in Kosher wine. From here in Jerusalem, Israel, we will uncover the latest trends, speak to the industry's movers and shakers, and point out ways to quickly improve your wine-tasting experience. Please tune in for some serious fun while we explore and experience The Kosher Terroir...
www.TheKosherTerroir.com
+972-58-731-1567
+1212-999-4444
TheKosherTerroir@gmail.com
Link to Join “The Kosher Terroir” WhatsApp Chat
https://chat.whatsapp.com/EHmgm2u5lQW9VMzhnoM7C9
Thursdays 6:30pm Eastern Time on the NSN Network
and the NSN App
The Kosher Terroir
The Great Wine Illusion Part 3 - The Taste Of Reputation
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Send a Text Message to The Kosher Terroir
A counterfeit Burgundy can taste “perfect” if the room believes it’s real. That’s not just a wine scandal, it’s a mirror, and it leads us to the hardest question in our Great Wine Illusion series: how much of greatness is in the glass, and how much is in the story we drink with it?
I call my friend Jeff Morgan because he’s lived on both sides of the label. Jeff tasted professionally for Wine Spectator, scored California wines weekly, and later founded Covenant Winery, one of the defining names in modern kosher wine. He tells me the wine that changed his life wasn’t famous or expensive at all, and that confession opens the door to everything else: why some old bottles turn silky and alive while others die into bitter “acid water,” why Champagne can survive a century, and why “drinkability on release” matters more than cellar dreams.
From there we test the myths we love. We put legendary bottles back on trial, talk volatile acidity and stuck fermentations, and confront a truth most of us avoid: even experienced tasters can be steered by reputation, region, and expectation. Jeff shares a blind tasting where a top critic mistakes his Long Island Chardonnay for great white Burgundy, and we trace how kosher wine moved from awkward early tastings to serious scores, long before many people were willing to believe it.
If you care about wine tasting, blind tasting, kosher wine, terroir, wine scores, and the psychology of flavor, this one is for you. Subscribe, share this with a friend who “only drinks the good stuff,” and leave a review so more listeners can find the series.
For More Information:
Covenant Winery
Jeff & Jodie Morgan and Geoff Rochwarger, Owners
Jeff Morgan, Founding Winemaker
Phone: +1 (510) 559-9045
E-Mail: wine@covenantwines.com
Address: 1102 6th Street
Berkeley, California 94710
Web Site: www.CovenantWines.com
www.TheKosherTerroir.com
+972-58-731-1567
+1212-999-4444
TheKosherTerroir@gmail.com
Link to Join “The Kosher Terroir” WhatsApp Chat
https://chat.whatsapp.com/EHmgm2u5lQW9VMzhnoM7C9
Thursdays 6:30pm Eastern Time on the NSN Network and the NSN App
Transcript — The Great Wine Illusion, Part 3: The Taste of Reputation
Nov 16, 2026 · @Simon
About this transcript
This is the transcript of the corrected final episode (The_Great_Wine_Illusion_Part_3_Jeff_Morgan_Final - 11/16/26 11:04 AM.mp3, 77:10), with a timestamp at the start of each paragraph. Timestamps are accurate to about a second.
- Speakers: SIMON is Simon Jacob, the host. JEFF is Jeff Morgan of Covenant. The interview was recorded by phone.
- Corrections: names, wines, places and wine terms are fixed against the script and the trilogy plan (Ponsot, Clos Saint-Denis, Ya'acov Oryah, Vitkin, Carignan, Cheval Blanc, Château Musar, Jancis Robinson, Chassagne-Montrachet, Levana, Au Bon Climat, Clos de Gat and others).
- What it follows: what is said on the audio, not the script, wherever you departed from it. Jeff's "um", "uh" and false starts are trimmed; his wording is kept.
- Section headings are added for navigation only; they aren't spoken.
Updated for the corrected audio. The overlap near the end is fixed: your closing narration on the people at the table now plays cleanly at 68:40–69:40, and Jeff's goodbye is gone. Timestamps after the opening run 1–2½ minutes later than in the earlier file, because of the added breaks between sections.
Transcript
Welcome
[00:01] SIMON: Welcome to The Kosher Terroir. I'm Simon Jacob, your host for this episode, from Jerusalem. Before we start, wherever you are, please take a moment to pray for the safe return home of all of our soldiers. If you're driving in your car, keep your eyes on the road. If you're home, pour yourself a glass of wonderful kosher wine, sit back and enjoy.
Cold open
[00:36] SIMON: New York, April 2008. An auction catalogue lands on the desks of the world's serious collectors. Among the lots, bottles of Clos Saint-Denis from Domaine Ponsot, one of the most respected names in Burgundy. Vintages going back to 1945.
[01:00] SIMON: In Burgundy, Laurent Ponsot reads the catalogue, and he gets on a plane. Because his family didn't make Clos Saint-Denis in 1945. Or in the fifties, or the sixties, or the seventies. Their first vintage of that wine was 1982.
[01:25] SIMON: He walks into the auction room and has the lots pulled. Years later, in a federal courtroom, he looks at those bottles and says, simply, "This cannot exist."
[01:38] SIMON: The man who had consigned them was a collector named Rudy Kurniawan. He was convicted of wine fraud. By some estimates, as many as 10,000 of his bottles may still be sitting in cellars around the world.
[01:54] SIMON: And here's the part I can't stop thinking about. For years before anyone caught him, serious, experienced people opened those bottles, tasted them, and praised them. They wrote notes. They paid fortunes.
[02:12] SIMON: So what were they tasting?
[02:16] SIMON: I put a version of that question to a man who spent eight years tasting for one of the most powerful wine magazines in America. And here's how he answered it.
[02:27] JEFF: Don't believe everything you read.
[02:30] SIMON: Don't believe everything you read. Tonight, I'd add: and don't be so sure about everything you taste.
[02:39] SIMON: This is The Kosher Terroir. And this is The Great Wine Illusion, Part 3: The Taste of Reputation.
Introduction
[02:49] SIMON: In Part 1, we went looking for the great wines of the past, and we found them. A duke who fired a grape. A family in Bordeaux who understood that a wine with a name was worth more than a wine without one. But we also found that some of the most celebrated bottles of the last century were great almost by accident. I called it the end of luck.
[03:18] SIMON: In Part 2, we sat with a winemaker who uses almost every tool science has given us. Ya'acov Oryah told us a wine today is "a vector of a thousand small decisions." And he left us with a warning: when wines start to taste alike, it isn't because of precision. It's because of decision. Somebody decides whom the wine is meant to please.
[03:47] SIMON: Tonight is about that somebody. Us. If science can change what's in the bottle, the label can change what's in our heads. The price, the name, the score, the story somebody told us before the cork came out. So the question for tonight is the hardest of the three. How much of greatness is in the glass, and how much is in the story?
[04:19] SIMON: I wanted to put that question to someone who has stood on both sides of the label. I can't think of anyone who fits that better than my friend Jeff Morgan.
[04:31] SIMON: Jeff went to France at nineteen to study music, and he came home with wine in his blood. He made his first commercial wine on Long Island in 1989. Then he crossed over. From the end of 1991 to 1999, he wrote and tasted for Wine Spectator, and from 1995 he was one of three critics in San Francisco scoring California's wines every week.
[05:04] SIMON: And then he crossed back. In 2003, with his wife, Jodie Morgan, he founded Covenant, a kosher winery in California. Today it's in Berkeley. And one of his wines has received the score every winemaker dreams of and almost none receive: a perfect 100. So Jeff has judged. And he has been judged.
[05:31] SIMON: We spoke by phone while he was here in Israel. You'll hear a little construction in the background now and then. I left it in.
[05:39] SIMON: So here's the map for tonight. We'll start with the wine that stopped Jeff in his tracks, which turns out not to be the one you'd expect. We'll ask whether the winemakers of fifty years ago really were leaving things to luck. Jeff isn't so sure, and I've kept our disagreement on the air. We'll put a legend from Part 1 back on trial, and hear about a famous critic, a blind tasting, and a Chardonnay from Long Island. We'll learn how a habit can teach you to love a fault. We'll go back to Jeff's very first assignment as a critic, a tasting of kosher wine that didn't go well. We'll also look at what science says happens in your brain when you see the price tag. And at the end, we'll find out what Jeff remembers when he remembers a great bottle.
[06:47] SIMON: And I'll ask Jeff the question I've asked every guest in this series. The greatest wine you've ever had: if it were made again tomorrow, would it still astonish you?
The wine that stopped him
[07:00] SIMON: I began where I've begun with every guest in this series. Not with the most expensive wine Jeff ever tasted, or the most famous. The one that stopped him. I expected a legend. A first growth, maybe, or a great Burgundy from a famous year. Listen to what he gave me instead.
[07:24] SIMON: Welcome to The Kosher Terroir, Jeff, first of all. That's number one.
[07:28] JEFF: All right. Nice to be here.
[07:32] SIMON: I wish you were here in person, but it's a pleasure to have you on anyway. Think of the greatest wines you've ever had. Not the most expensive; the one that stopped you. Where were you, and who were you with?
[07:51] JEFF: Well, it's not always the greatest wines that stop me. Sometimes a lot of it is context and timing. For example, one of the greatest wine experiences I ever had was at the age of nineteen, when I moved to France as a music student at the French National Conservatory. And for lunch, which was government-subsidized, it cost me two francs, the equivalent of fifty cents. I was offered a half bottle, or a split, smaller than a half bottle, of white wine. This is at lunch, remember, with my four-course meal.
[08:38] JEFF: I realized, just looking at the food, that I couldn't recognize most of it, and that I probably had been eating badly most of my life growing up in New York. Nonetheless, I took a sip of that cheap white wine along with my céleri rémoulade salad and realized, as did Dom Pérignon when he figured out how to make Champagne, that I was seeing stars, and that my life would change forever. That little glass — I have no idea what that wine was. It was white, and I actually spent an extra twenty-five centimes for the split — was the beginning of the change in my life. Probably it was mediocre, but it went great with my lunch.
[09:31] JEFF: So you never know. However, the other night I was with Assaf Paz from Vitkin Winery, and he brought a number of wines to dinner, and one of them was a 2003 Vitkin Carignan. So, a 23-year-old red wine. And I was startled at how beautifully fresh and alive it was. What had evolved, I think, over time were the tannins, which tend to drop out of solution, so it was very silky smooth. And that allows the flavors, in this case many primary flavors, to reveal themselves. So was this one of the greatest wines I'd ever had? I don't know, but it was certainly a great wine-drinking experience with a good friend.
[10:28] SIMON: A split of cheap white wine. Twenty-five centimes extra, at a subsidized student lunch in France. He has no idea what it was. He thinks it was probably mediocre. And it changed his life.
[10:46] SIMON: That's the first thing I want you to notice tonight. The greatest wine experience of a man who went on to judge thousands of wines professionally had almost nothing to do with the wine. It had to do with being nineteen, and far from home, and looking at a plate of food he didn't recognize, and realizing the world was bigger than he'd thought.
[11:12] SIMON: And then the second wine. If you were with us for Part 1, you'll remember the chapter on Carignan: the workhorse grape of the south of France, planted for volume, part of an ocean of ordinary wine. Here it is twenty-three years later, poured by Assaf Paz of Vitkin, fresh and alive. That 2003 bottle was made before Vitkin's wines carried a hashgacha; the winery has been kosher for more than a decade now. But what Jeff tasted that night is the same lesson Ya'acov gave us in Part 2. The grape didn't change. What people chose to do with it did.
[12:00] SIMON: I pressed him, though, because my question was really about the old bottles. The legends.
[12:05] JEFF: I think, more specifically to your question: people think that wine gets better with age. Well, some do and many don't. It kind of depends on how a wine is structured to begin with. Wines with good acidity, which would be more white wines, or wines that have gone through malolactic, both whites and reds, tend to age better than more soft-structured wines with lower acidity. Now, that doesn't necessarily apply to red wines like Cabernet Sauvignon, especially from California and from Israel, which have very low acidity but good tannin structures. Those tannins, if they resolve nicely with time, can reveal a more approachable wine that is easier to enjoy. So did the wine get better with age after ten years? Maybe. It certainly became more approachable.
[13:10] JEFF: In terms of old red wines, what are some of the greatest wines I've ever had? Well, I had an 1898 Lafite Rothschild once, and I was very surprised at how well that had aged. It was over a century old when I had it.
[13:29] SIMON: How had it aged, that you found interesting?
[13:32] JEFF: It was softer. I don't know if it was softer, because I never had it when it was young, but it was just lovely. It was smooth and silky, and it had all sorts of fresh fruit flavors still, as well as what we call secondary and tertiary flavors. It wasn't old and moldy, as some wines can be.
[13:54] JEFF: I remember I was in the cellar of a Burgundy cellar, I don't know, twenty years ago, writing some article about Burgundy, and the Burgundians wanted to convince me that they drank more than just Burgundy. And this young vintner pulled out a bottle of — I guess it was 1923 Château Canon, which is a Bordeaux. And we opened it with great excitement and enthusiasm, and in fact, it was terrible. That can happen.
[14:35] SIMON: You're putting it up to chance.
[14:37] JEFF: Yeah. But the thing is — so what was so terrible? Well, the acid had remained, so it was very bitter. The flavors had completely disappeared, and it was like drinking some kind of acidy water. It was horrible. And so, you know what we did? We drank the whole bottle anyway, because how often do you get to open a 1923 anything? So it was a great experience.
[15:06] JEFF: I have to say, now that I'm thinking about it, I once had lunch with the late Christian Pol-Roger, whose family's Champagne house produced some excellent, excellent Champagnes over the last century, and one of them is known as Winston Churchill. That's the label. I was doing an article for Wine Spectator, and my assignment was: does Champagne age? And every Champagne house I went to was thrilled to greet me, because they had an excuse to open their oldest bubblies, right?
[15:51] JEFF: So I went to see Christian Pol-Roger, and he greeted me in his office, and he opened a bottle of 1975 bubbly, and he served it to me with Parmesan cheese, which at the time I didn't realize was a standard practice in Champagne. You enjoy your nutty aged bubbly with your nutty Parmesan cheese. It's a beautiful match.
[16:18] SIMON: I never even thought about that, but I'm going to try that.
[16:23] JEFF: Sounds delicious. And then — I speak fluent French, and he didn't know I spoke fluent French, so even though his English was perfect, we digressed into French and we got really cozy. And he said, "Gee, my wife is making lunch at home for me. Why don't you come and have lunch with me at my house?" Which was very exciting to me, because you don't often get invited into famous vintners' homes for lunch to drink old bubbly.
[16:54] JEFF: So we go to his house, and his wife indeed was in the kitchen, which was in the basement of their house, cooking away. I have no idea what we ate, but I know that we started with a magnum of 1914 Pol Roger, which was disgorged — I guess it was disgorged in maybe '45 or '47, shortly after the war.
[17:25] SIMON: Was that good?
[17:26] JEFF: Wow. That wine — I couldn't believe how well it had aged. Bubbly is aged on the lees, so that would have been a very late-disgorged wine. The lees are antioxidants, so they really slow down the evolution of a Champagne made with the méthode champenoise. These old, old bubblies, when stored properly, can reveal just exquisite texture and flavors and give you an amazing experience. So that was noteworthy.
[18:01] JEFF: Another vintner I visited in Champagne greeted me at his door and said, "I really don't have a lot of old, old bubbly, because the Nazis occupied my winery, took over, and they either drank everything or broke all the bottles. But we did hide a few bottles behind a wall in the cellar that they never found." And he brought out a bottle of 1930-something, and I said, "Oh, that's my mother's birth year." At which point he said, "We're not opening this. You take it home." But then he found a bottle of 1953, which is my birth year, and we drank that, and it was pretty damn good.
[18:45] JEFF: So to me, it's always a surprise when a wine, which is simply a living beverage, can live so long. I would say, though, that most wines that I drink are not so old. I think well-made wines should taste very, very good as soon as they're opened. I mean, I'm drinking 2024 Merlot from my own winery that is just astoundingly smooth and delicious.
[19:31] JEFF: So I think today's winemakers know how to — in a world where we say, "Oh, we're not manipulating, it's less intervention in the winemaking process" — well, you don't have to intervene to know how to make a wine that is drinkable in its youth. You don't have to add anything. In the winemaking process, you do things to keep the tannin softer and riper. So I do think the primary flavors that are apparent in young wines, red and white, can be beautiful and seductive. And as the wine gets older, they may evolve in a positive way, just like people, or a not-so-positive way, just like people. And the only way to know if the wine is going to taste better, so to speak, or really good after it's ten, fifteen, twenty, thirty, whatever years old, is to open it and try it.
[20:41] SIMON: Yep. Wow. I agree with you a hundred percent.
[20:45] SIMON: "The only way to know is to open it." Hold on to two of those bottles. An 1898, more than a century old, still silky, still full of fruit. And a 1923 from Bordeaux that had turned into what Jeff called acidy water. Horrible, he said. And what did they do? They drank the whole bottle. Because, in his words, how often do you get to open a 1923 anything?
[21:18] SIMON: I love that story, and I think it's the whole of tonight's episode in one glass. The wine was gone. The story wasn't. They weren't drinking what was in the bottle. They were drinking the year on the label, the cellar it came out of, the young vintner who wanted to impress a visiting writer. That's what reputation tastes like.
[21:43] SIMON: And notice where Jeff ends up. Not in a cellar full of old bottles, but at his own table with a young Merlot from his own winery, Covenant, from the 2024 vintage. Well-made wine, he says, should taste very good the day you open it. Some wines age beautifully. Most just get older. Ya'acov told us the same thing last time, almost word for word.
[22:11] SIMON: Which made me wonder about something I said at the very start of this series. I said the great wines of the past were often great by luck. So I asked Jeff whether the winemakers he knew in France were leaving things to luck. He didn't let me off easy.
Was it ever luck?
[22:31] SIMON: Here's the case I made in Part 1. For most of history, a winemaker had the place and the year, and very little else. He couldn't cool a vat that was running too hot. He couldn't measure ripeness in a lab. He couldn't give a thirsty vine a drink in August. When a great wine came out of that, there was luck in it.
[22:57] SIMON: Jeff has been making wine since 1989, in New York, in California, and here even in Israel. I wanted to know if he saw it the same way. What were winemakers there still leaving to luck that you never leave to luck today?
[23:13] JEFF: I've been making wine, I guess, since 1989, in New York and California and Israel. And basically, there are viticultural practices that are time-honored, that haven't changed since the seventies or before that, involving canopy management, for example, and how much light your vines get, your grapes get. So that hasn't changed much.
[23:49] JEFF: In the old days, aka the seventies, they were still using native yeast in France. And Michel Rolland once told me that they were using less native yeast because they'd used so many pesticides in the vineyards during that time that native yeast coming out of the vineyard were not so viable anymore. So they started using more commercial yeast. But I'm sure there were plenty of people still using native. And certainly in California, I've been using native yeast since, I don't know, 2008, pretty much exclusively. Works fine.
[24:34] JEFF: So I think basically winemaking has kind of remained the same. Basic fermentation techniques. Okay, maybe we use a little less oak, or a little more oak. We have irrigators to help in the tanks during fermentation for reds, and that gives easier and better coverage of the cap with the juice that's fermenting, and that can yield softer tannins. Maybe we get our wines riper today because of global warming; it's warmer than it used to be. I don't know. But I would say good winemakers paid attention to details that create quality in your glass, back in the day and today. And I would be very surprised if I was transported fifty years into the past and saw that there was a great difference between what was being done then and what's done now.
[25:41] SIMON: Well, things like, as an example: chillers. Labs right there on location. Drip lines. That sort of stuff has got to have changed. As an example, let me ask you: the drip lines are on almost every vine here, though there's some movement back to pulling those and using only naturally irrigated vines. But in California, it varies as well. Does controlling the water do anything to the flavor of the wine, or just to the yield?
[26:25] JEFF: Yes. For everything. Everything affects everything. So if you add more water to the ground, and more water is sucked up by your plant, well, if added at the wrong time, it can dilute flavors in the wine. Absolutely. Or it can increase yields, which again might dilute flavors in the wine. So overirrigation can be a problem in some vineyards, particularly vineyards that are more industrially designed for quantity rather than quality. But in places like Burgundy and Bordeaux, it's still illegal to irrigate.
[27:12] JEFF: They're changing their tune now as the weather gets hotter and hotter, because it's very hard to grow grapes effectively in hundred-degree weather that lasts for a week, with vines getting no water. That'll give you a wilted vine and dried-up fruit.
[27:37] JEFF: And then the dry farming. Well, that's very nice, but if you've been irrigating your vines for ten years and then you want to go to dry farming, that could be a problem. You're going to kill them all. Well, you won't necessarily kill them. But the way you want to start a dry-farmed vineyard is you plant the vines and you give them a little water to get started over the first year or two, and then you let those roots find their way down into the ground and find the nearest water source. Hopefully there is one. But once you've been irrigating for a long time, those roots don't want to go down anymore. They stay closer to the surface, where the irrigation water comes from.
[28:10] JEFF: So I think that anybody who says, "Oh, I do it this way, and that makes my wine better," is, as we say, proverbially full of — [bleep]. Okay. It ain't that way. If it's working, and your vines are old and dry-farmed, or even new and dry-farmed, fantastic. That's great. But you'd better have a water source that's somewhat close to the surface, so that your roots, even if they go down, I don't know, twenty, thirty feet, don't have to go much farther to find the water.
[28:51] JEFF: And then in California, unless you're in a very moist area, I think you're out of your mind not to use drip irrigation, which of course we know is Israeli-invented. Because that gives you the control that you need. You can put a little bit on, you can put a gallon on, you can put two gallons on. If you know that you've got a week coming where temperatures are going to be close to a hundred degrees, well, you might give your vines three gallons in advance, a day or two before the heat spike comes, to give them some sustenance to fight back. And it works. And if you wait till the heat starts, it's too late.
[29:36] SIMON: I said at the start of this series that I wanted an investigation, not a verdict. So here is the evidence against me, from a man who knows. Good winemakers, Jeff says, always paid attention to the details that put quality in the glass. If he went back fifty years, he'd be surprised to find much difference in what they did.
[30:01] SIMON: I think he's right about the good ones. The monks and the dukes we met in Part 1 weren't fools. They chose their slopes, they pruned hard, and they picked with care.
[30:12] SIMON: But listen to where the conversation went when I pushed. Water, he said, affects everything. And then he described exactly the kind of control we spent Part 2 on: a vineyard manager watching the forecast, seeing a week near a hundred degrees coming, and giving every vine three gallons a day or two before the heat arrives. Wait until the heat starts, he said, and it's too late. That's not luck. And it's an Israeli tool he's reaching for: drip irrigation, born in the Negev in the 1960s.
[30:50] SIMON: One footnote, for the record. Jeff says it's still illegal to irrigate in Bordeaux and Burgundy. That's the rule he grew up with, and it's still the starting point. France banned irrigation in its appellation vineyards in 1964. But since 2006, the authorities have allowed exceptions in the hottest weeks of summer, case by case, and they loosened the rules again in 2017. Which is exactly his point about the heat: even the French are learning to give the vines a drink.
[31:31] SIMON: So where does that leave us? Here's where I've come out. Jeff and I aren't really disagreeing about the great winemakers. We're disagreeing about everybody else. The best of them always minded the details. What has changed is how many winemakers can mind them, in how many places, and how often it works. Greatness was never only luck. But repeating it was.
A legend on trial
[32:00] SIMON: Which brings us to the most famous accident in this whole series. In Part 1, I told you about Cheval Blanc 1947: a summer so hot the fermentation stuck, a wine that today's labs would flag for its volatile acidity, and that collectors still treat as one of the greatest reds of the century. In Part 2, Ya'acov defended it, as a winemaker. I asked Jeff whether he'd ever keep a fault like that in his own wine, because it made the wine more interesting. He answered as a critic. Here's the question, exactly as I asked it.
[32:40] SIMON: In 1947, Cheval Blanc had a stuck fermentation and high volatile acidity, and it became a legend. If your fermentation stuck today, or tomorrow — I'm not wishing that on you at all — would you ever let it be? Is there any fault that you would keep because it makes the wine more interesting?
[33:11] JEFF: Well, a stuck fermentation doesn't imply volatile acidity, VA. In a stuck ferment, if you've got a little residual sugar left in the wine, there are a number of options. You can do nothing. And typically what happens, if the wine is going through malolactic fermentation, the malolactic bacteria will eat through all the malic acid, and then they're still hungry. And what do they go for after the malic acid? They will go for the sugar that remains in the wine.
[33:51] JEFF: And what happens when a nice little malolactic bacterium eats sugar is not what happens when it eats malic acid. When it eats malic acid, it turns it into lactic acid. That gives a certain richness and creaminess to the texture of the wine. When it eats sugar, you get volatile acidity. You get acetic acid. And a little bit of VA is in a lot of wines, maybe a little tiny bit, and it can enhance flavors. But once the wine starts to remind me of the beginning of vinegar, then it's no fun.
[34:17] JEFF: One of the most famous wines in the world that is almost always volatile is Château Musar, the famous Lebanese producer of often beautiful wines that eventually are not so beautiful, because with age they're always super volatile and undrinkable. But younger, they're really good. I never had the '47 Cheval Blanc. I don't know how volatile it was.
[35:00] SIMON: Oh, you haven't had it either.
[35:02] JEFF: So basically — wait, so who gave you this information?
[35:11] SIMON: It's one of those bottles that is worth a million bucks. Crazy money.
[35:17] JEFF: Yeah. Well, a couple of things. I believe '47 was a really great vintage, although not as great as my vintage, when I was born, which was '53.
[35:27] SIMON: I'm a '54 baby.
[35:29] JEFF: '54 wasn't so great either. So, although we don't have the wide discrepancies in California wines that the Europeans had, especially back in the day, because there were very different growing conditions every year — California is a little more stable. But where was I going here? As a former wine writer, and as a good friend of many wine writers, I think it's important for your listeners to understand that most wine writers often get it wrong. As did I, back in the day. Sometimes they get it right, but I don't believe that any old wine with a lot of VA is going to taste any good. So that sounds very suspect to me.
[36:16] JEFF: You know who Jancis Robinson is? The famous — okay. So the great Jancis Robinson once was tasting a wine I made in New York, on Long Island. It was a Chardonnay, and it was a blind tasting of great Burgundies, and they threw my wine in. It was a 1989 Gristina Chardonnay from the North Fork of Long Island. It was my first vintage ever, and it was a really rough vintage. It rained a lot, but we were using the best methodology we could to keep the grapes ripe and rot-free, and we bottled it somehow. I don't even know how we got into this tasting. I think we got a good score from Wine Spectator.
[37:10] JEFF: And so Jancis is up there with a panel of wine experts, and they're tasting through Burgundies, and she tastes this one wine that was her favorite, and she said, "My God, this must be the great Chassagne-Montrachet from the famous Burgundy vineyard." And of course it was my wine, from Long Island. You know what's really cool? By that time I was no longer working at that vineyard. I had become a writer myself, and I was covering this for the New York Times. So I got to write about Jancis Robinson misidentifying a wine I had made on Long Island as a great Burgundy, but I couldn't say that I had made the wine. But it was very cool. I still have that article, about Jancis. And whenever I see her, I never hesitate to remind her of that snafu, and she laughs also. So what I'm saying is, you know —
[38:14] SIMON: So what Jeff was saying, before I so rudely interrupted him, was: don't believe everything you read.
[38:21] SIMON: I owe you an honest follow-up, because I told you the Cheval Blanc story in Part 1, and here's a critic taking it apart.
[38:31] SIMON: First, the chemistry. A stuck fermentation, Jeff says, doesn't by itself give you volatile acidity. The trouble starts afterwards. If sugar is left in the wine, the bacteria that carry out the malolactic fermentation finish their proper work on the malic acid, and then, still hungry, they turn to the sugar. That's when you get acetic acid, and the first breath of vinegar.
[39:00] SIMON: Second, the doubt. Jeff has never tasted the '47. Neither have I. The figures I gave you in Part 1 are the published ones: a little over a gram per liter of volatile acidity, a touch of sugar left behind. Jeff's view is that a great old wine with a lot of volatile acidity sounds suspect, and that wine writers often get it wrong, himself included, back in the day.
[39:31] SIMON: So who's right? I honestly don't know. And I think that's the point. Almost nobody alive has tasted that wine, and almost everybody who loves wine has an opinion about it. For most of us, Cheval Blanc 1947 isn't a taste at all. It's a story.
[39:52] SIMON: And then Jeff told me a story of his own, and I think it's the best evidence in this whole series. A panel of experts tasting great white Burgundies, blind. One of the most respected critics in the world picks her favorite and names it as a great Chassagne-Montrachet. It was actually a Chardonnay from the North Fork of Long Island. 1989, a wet, difficult year, and Jeff's first vintage ever. But by then he'd left the winery and become a wine writer himself. He covered the tasting for the New York Times, and he couldn't tell his readers that he'd been the one to make that wine.
[40:39] SIMON: That's what a blind tasting does. It takes the story away. No famous name, no famous slope, no price. Just what's in the glass. And with the story gone, an expert's palate went straight past the reputation of Burgundy and landed on a young winemaker from Long Island.
The strangest tasting
[41:01] SIMON: At the end of 1991, Jeff is living on Long Island. He's stopped making wine, and he's trying to build a career as a writer. Wine Spectator gives him his first assignment: the Passover round-up. Kosher wine. I asked him what kosher wine tasted like in those days. He didn't hesitate.
[41:24] SIMON: …was the Passover kosher roundup. What did kosher wine taste like then?
[41:32] JEFF: Pretty bad.
[41:33] SIMON: Okay. Thanks for being honest.
[41:34] JEFF: No, it's true. I remember — I was still living in the wine country of New York, out on Long Island. I had stopped making wine, and I had this budding career as a wine writer, so I was freelancing for the Spectator. And they told me, "Well, just buy a bunch of kosher wine and taste it, and write." I wasn't really doing a review. I was more writing about what kashrut is. I went to some restaurants, some great restaurants, and I had some meals. Looking back, I've reread the article. It's less about quality and more about the essence of kashrut. And I was surprised that I got a lot of it right, maybe thanks to some commentary by our friend Jay Buchsbaum.
[42:24] JEFF: But anyway, I'll always remember this tasting. A lot of my friends were winemakers out on Long Island, good winemakers, and I decided not to taste the wines myself, but to invite them to do a blind tasting with me, and not tell them the wines were kosher. I remember Dan Kleck, who eventually became a winemaker for Kendall-Jackson, and a bunch of other guys were there. We were tasting, I had like eight or nine wines, and we get about halfway through, fourth or fifth wine. They were pretty weird, these wines, in various states of weirdness. There were a few that tasted normal, but a lot of them were just bizarre. And from around the world. And at one point, Dan Kleck looks at me and he goes, "This is the strangest tasting I've ever experienced, Jeff. What's going on here?"
[43:26] JEFF: And I think the issue was not that kosher was bad. I didn't have any Mogen David or Manischewitz in the lineup. It was real wine. I think this was in, what, 1991, right? And there were some very good kosher wines out there at the time, because just a few years later we were giving over-90 scores to a number of kosher brands that were submitting their wines to the Spectator, including Herzog. But I think it was just the beginning of a serious approach to winemaking in the kosher realm. And I didn't know what to buy. I didn't know where to look. I was a neophyte. I didn't know anything about kosher wine, so I just happened upon some odd examples of the genre.
[44:27] JEFF: There weren't many bottles available at that time. I remember I went to dinner at Levana, the great, late restaurant in Manhattan. They were serving non-mevushal Bordeaux, and I had a bottle of really good kosher non-mevushal Bordeaux. I don't remember what it was. With my meal — was it a dairy meal, or was it meat?
[45:04] SIMON: No, it was meat. It started as a dairy restaurant.
[45:09] JEFF: But when I got there, it was meat. You know what kind of meat I had? So I had my non-mevushal Bordeaux, and I had dinner with Tom Matthews, who at the time was the New York editor and eventually became the editor-in-chief. So we had a very nice bottle of kosher Bordeaux, and my main course was venison.
[45:33] SIMON: Yeah, they used to do that.
[45:35] JEFF: So I had kosher venison and Bordeaux. And the thing I remember most about the meal, aside from the fact that it tasted really good, was that I was so nervous, because it was my first article for Wine Spectator, that my hands were shaking. I was trying to write my notes on my little journalist's pad, and I didn't want Tom Matthews to see I was a shaking, nervous mess. But apparently I passed the test, as did that meal. And eventually, obviously, we've discovered that the world is filled with great kosher wine today.
[46:12] SIMON: Jeff had said kosher wine was pretty bad. I thanked him for his honesty, and I meant it. But listen to what he actually did. He didn't taste those wines himself, knowing what they were. He poured them blind for a group of serious Long Island winemakers, without telling them the wines were kosher. One of them, Dan Kleck, went on to make wine for Kendall-Jackson in California. Halfway through, he looked up and asked Jeff what on earth was going on.
[46:46] SIMON: So the verdict wasn't prejudice. Nobody in that room knew there was a hashgacha on any of the bottles. The wines were judged on what was in the glass, and in 1991, much of what was in the glass was pretty strange.
[47:04] SIMON: And yet, in that same week, at Levana in Manhattan, Jeff sat across from his editor with a kosher, non-mevushal Bordeaux and a plate of kosher venison. A very good bottle. And within a few years, he says, the Spectator was giving scores in the nineties to kosher wines, Herzog among them.
[47:26] SIMON: Here's what I take from this part of the episode. The idea that kosher wine is something you drink out of duty rather than desire — Jeff's first tasting showed how that reputation was earned. His first thirty years show how it was lost. Reputation follows the glass, but it follows slowly. The wine got good long before most people were willing to believe it.
[47:56] SIMON: Which raises the question every critic has to face. When you know what's in the bottle, can you ever really taste it fresh?
Bagged bottles
[48:04] SIMON: If you've listened to the episode "Your Next Favorite Wine Lives Next Door," you'll remember the brain-scan study. I'll only remind you of the headline. In 2008, researchers at Caltech and Stanford gave people the same wine twice, once labeled at five dollars and once at forty-five. Another wine was shown at ten dollars and at ninety. People said they enjoyed the "expensive" pours more, and the parts of their brain that register pleasure agreed with them. Weeks later, tasting blind, the same people preferred the cheapest wine.
[48:47] SIMON: The same year, three more pieces of evidence arrived. The wine writer Robin Goldstein, working with economists, gathered more than six thousand blind tastings by about five hundred people. Without the price in front of them, ordinary wine drinkers liked the expensive wines slightly less. Trained tasters liked them a little more.
[49:16] SIMON: A winemaker and retired statistician, Robert Hodgson, ran a quiet experiment at the California State Fair. He gave the judges the same wine three times in the same flight. A typical judge's scores for that one wine moved by about four points either way.
[49:36] SIMON: And there's the famous French study you may have heard of, where a white wine colored red drew descriptions of red wine. Be careful with that one: the tasters were students of wine in Bordeaux, not seasoned experts, and the tasting part was never fully peer-reviewed.
[49:56] SIMON: None of this shows that famous wines are worse. It shows that expectation is part of the meal. So I asked the man who sat on the other side of the table.
[50:05] SIMON: Did you taste blind at the Spectator? And let me ask you a question that maybe you won't want to answer. Did you ever change a score once you knew what the wine was, or what it cost?
[50:21] JEFF: Well, okay. Let's remember that I left the Spectator twenty-six years ago, so I've spent more of my wine life not being at the Spectator. I was there for eight years, and I became a regular reviewer in '95, when I moved to California. Every Tuesday we would spend all day tasting. It was Harvey Steiman, it was James Laube, and it was me. The three of us were the tasters, in the offices that were at the time still in San Francisco.
[50:57] JEFF: And everything was blind. Each of us had our own flight prepared by the tasting coordinator. It wasn't double-blind. Double-blind means you know nothing about the wine: you don't know the vintage, you don't know where it's from. This was simply blind. The bottles were bagged so that you wouldn't see the label. But we would know what region it came from. Say it was Napa Valley Cabernet: we would know that, and the vintage.
[51:24] JEFF: So in a sense it keeps you honest. But at the same time, as soon as you know it's from Napa and it's Cabernet, well, you're probably programmed to give a little higher score than if it's Cabernet from Berkeley, California, where my winery is located, which is too cold to grow Cabernet. So it was as objectively subjective as you could be.
[51:53] JEFF: I never knew what I was tasting until after I unbagged it. However, if you really didn't like something so much, and you unbagged it, and it was a winery you knew, and you knew that typically these wines were much better — we would often have two samples in the tasting room, so we'd schedule it for a retasting at some point in the near future. We wouldn't know if it would be the following week or the following month, but it would be retasted. And as I recall, if it came out tasting like [bleep] both times, and it was a famous brand, we'd give it the low score, and we'd write "tasted twice." And if it came out tasting, blind, like what we expected that brand to taste like, we'd use the higher score.
[52:55] SIMON: "As objectively subjective as you could be." I think that's the most honest description of wine criticism I've ever heard. The bottles were in bags, but the critics knew the region and the vintage. And as soon as you know it's Napa Cabernet, Jeff says, you're probably programmed to give it a little more.
[53:17] SIMON: That's not a confession of cheating. It's what the science says happens to all of us. The label doesn't have to be visible to do its work. A word is enough.
[53:30] SIMON: The most famous blind tasting of all took place while Jeff was living in France. Paris, 1976. A panel of French experts tasted the best of Bordeaux and Burgundy against unknown wines from California, blind. A California Cabernet, Stag's Leap 1973, finished ahead of a first growth, by a twentieth of a point. The French answer was that California wines wouldn't age. Thirty years later, in 2006, they ran the tasting again with the same wines. The top five reds were all Californian. Reputation predicted one result. The glass gave another. Twice.
[54:21] SIMON: So I asked Jeff: you were in France that year. Did anyone notice?
[54:28] SIMON: You know, you were in France. Were you in France in '76? So you were there during the Judgment of Paris. Did anyone around you notice the Judgment of Paris? Just asking.
[54:39] JEFF: Well, you've got to remember, in '76 I was a musician. I was twenty-three years old. I was living in France, living on, you know, bupkis, drinking whatever. My wine of choice was something called Bou Kebir [spelling unconfirmed], an Algerian red that I would buy at the local cave, the retailer, where I'd bring my empty bottle and put it under the barrel, and they'd fill it for me every couple of days. That was my wine of choice. Did I know about the Paris tasting in '76? I guess not. No, I didn't know. I just knew that I needed to have enough wine in my attic apartment in the old city of Nice to get me through the next meal.
[55:28] SIMON: I love it.
[55:31] SIMON: Algerian red, filled from the barrel into his own empty bottle every couple of days, in an attic in the old city of Nice. If you heard Part 1, you'll remember that Algeria once poured an ocean of wine into France. That twenty-three-year-old musician was drinking that ocean one bottle at a time, while the most famous tasting in history happened a few hundred miles north. He never heard a word about it.
[56:02] SIMON: I asked him one more thing about his years as a critic. Was there a famous bottle he went back to and found wanting?
[56:10] JEFF: Well, when you say "went back to," you mean something like —
[56:15] SIMON: I mean, you were reviewing a top-notch wine, and it still tasted like crap.
[56:19] JEFF: I don't recall doing that myself. I know some of my colleagues did. I remember the late, great Jim Clendenen, who started a wine brand called Au Bon Climat and really helped revolutionize California winemaking, particularly as a result of his winemaking experiences in Burgundy in the seventies. He got a 52 or a 53 for one of his wines from Wine Spectator. He was famous, and they kept that score, and he had it framed, and he proudly displayed that score as his most famous Wine Spectator review. And he had the right attitude, because he knew that this was kind of the luck of the draw sometimes, and he used that terrible score to enhance his image among his consumer base and his friends.
[57:13] JEFF: I might have given a wine an 87 or an 88 that probably would usually get a 92 or 93. We weren't quite as generous with scores back in the olden days. You almost never saw a 95. It was unheard of. When I gave something a 91 or a 92, it was like, wow. So we have something called score inflation now. I couldn't ever imagine a wine getting 100 points, because there is no such thing as a perfect wine. Now we got it. So I got one, as we know. So yeah, fantastic. But we didn't do that back in the day. Were we more honest? I don't know if we were more honest, but we were more conservative in our gauging of quality.
[58:20] SIMON: A great winemaker who framed his worst score and hung it on the wall. I love that. He knew that a number on a Tuesday, from one bottle, in one flight, is the luck of the draw. And he turned it into part of his legend.
[58:35] SIMON: And then the line I'd been waiting all series to hear. "There is no such thing as a perfect wine. But now we got one." You know the story of Covenant's hundred points; we told it in "What Makes a Wine Iconic?" I won't tell it here again. What I want you to hear is the man who once handed out a 91 as if it were gold, saying that in his day a 91 meant wow. Scores have climbed since then. Jeff doesn't say the old critics were more honest. He says they were more careful with their numbers. Which means that when you read a score, you're not really reading a wine. You're reading a decade.
[59:23] SIMON: So if the score is a story, and the label is a story, and the vintage on the bottle is a story, what's left? I asked Jeff the last question I always ask, and his answer took us to a place where I think greatness actually lives.
The people at the table
[59:44] SIMON: I ask every guest in this series a version of the same question. For Jeff, I took the label away. Of every wine you've ever had, which one would you most like to taste again, blind, and why?
[60:01] JEFF: I would love to taste my 1989 Gristina Chardonnay, the one that Jancis misidentified as a Chassagne-Montrachet. I would love to taste that wine again and see if it's weathered the last, what, thirty-five, thirty-six years. Because that was made like Burgundy. And I bet it has. That would be a high. And this also was the first wine I was involved with making, the first commercial wine. So that would be great.
[60:38] SIMON: Of course it's that one. The Long Island Chardonnay that a famous critic took for a great Burgundy. The wine that was blind from the very beginning, because nobody at that tasting knew its story. Thirty-seven years on, he wants to put it back in a glass with no label and see if it still stands up. He bets it has. I hope he gets to find out.
[61:06] SIMON: But Jeff isn't a man who lives in his cellar. Listen to how he talks about age. His own, and his wine's.
[61:14] SIMON: The year Covenant started was…
[61:20] JEFF: So our first vintage was in 2003. And we picked those grapes right around my fiftieth birthday. My advice to any fifty-year-olds today? Do it earlier. Start your brand ten years earlier.
[61:44] SIMON: A little early.
[61:45] JEFF: You know, it's kind of funny. Age gives you a very different perspective on things. People were coming to me with some of these incredible new Bordeaux wines, and even Burgundies — they're making exceptional wines kosher now — and "you've got to get at least a couple of cases." And I'm going, I'm seventy-two now. I'm not going to wait. Ten years from now I'll be in my eighties. Twenty years from now I'll be in my nineties. There are some wines that I've really appreciated twenty years after vintage. I don't know that I'm going to plan for my cellar to do that. It's just like, thanks, but… I should have started collecting earlier. I have plenty of old wine. Unfortunately, a lot of it's my own wine. Which I drink, but I'd rather drink other people's. It's kind of more exciting.
[62:54] JEFF: Today I buy a lot of wines, both from France and America. A little bit from Spain. Not so much from Italy, just because I don't understand Italian wine that well. I like it. But I buy mostly wines that I think are going to be drinking well immediately. I'll buy '20s, '23s, '24 reds that I have a hunch will drink really well. Now, it's not like they're not going to age. Sometimes I'll buy enough to keep a few bottles aside. But I'm not buying cases to wait ten years. I can tell you, my Cabernets, which are very age-worthy, taste really good upon release. They don't necessarily get better with age. They get different. So if you've got the time, and you've got the space in your cellar, and you want to hold on to some for a while, it's fun to see how they age. But really, the wines that I buy today are wines that I'm going to drink mostly within six months to a year.
[64:07] SIMON: "They don't necessarily get better with age. They get different." A man who has tasted wines from the nineteenth century, and makes wines built to last, now buys to drink within a year. That isn't a lack of patience. It's an answer to our series question. If great wine can be made on purpose, you don't have to wait twenty years and hope.
[64:34] SIMON: I told Jeff I'd been carrying bottles of his hundred-point wine back to Israel, one at a time. He had advice for me.
[64:41] SIMON: Is there any more of that hundred-point wine left anywhere?
[64:51] JEFF: Yeah, I know that there's — well, actually, there's a little left in Bayonne. And there certainly is, if someday you actually ever come to visit me in California. There's a bottle that we're going to share for dinner together.
[65:05] SIMON: Okay. So that's definite incentive for me to get out there. I just want you to know I have a couple of bottles here in Israel. I went out of my way to make sure that I got them, and I hand-carried them back to Israel, and they're sitting in my cellar, you know, detoxifying from the flying and all the rest of that.
[65:33] JEFF: Okay. But it tastes really good right now. If it didn't, it wouldn't have gotten 100 points.
[65:39] SIMON: You're a hundred percent right. That's true.
[65:41] JEFF: So I would not sit around for five years and wait. I would open a bottle, whenever you feel it has settled down from the flight.
[65:49] SIMON: I did open one of them. I admit it, I did taste it. But I still have two bottles here.
[65:58] SIMON: Don't wait five years. Duly noted, Jeff.
[66:02] SIMON: And then, just as we were about to say goodbye, Jeff asked if he could finish with one thought. I'm glad he did.
[66:11] JEFF: Let me just finish with one thought. You know what I like most about wine? I like the fact that every evening I ask Jodie, "What's for dinner?" She tells me what we're having for dinner, and then I can go down into the cellar and find a suitable wine to accompany our meal. That's almost more exciting and more fun to me than actually drinking it and having dinner. The anticipation of a great meal and a great bottle of wine is the high point of my day.
[66:53] JEFF: And my little one-and-a-half-year-old grandson, Razi — who's Zoe's son — if he's at the house with us, because his gan is right near our house, if he's around before dinner and he sees me going down to the cellar, he goes, "Saba, piki yayin! Piki yayin!" And that makes it even more exciting. So to me, wine is no longer so much about the flavors and the taste of wine, but about the experience. The full experience.
[67:33] JEFF: You know what? I remember the first wine I had in Israel, in 2011, when I first came here to look around, before I started making wine in Israel. I was in Jerusalem with Leslie Rudd, the late, great Leslie Rudd, my former partner, and we went to have dinner with my cousin Amy and her husband Barak, whose apartment I'm staying in right now — they have an apartment in Jerusalem also. And we sat down for dinner, and the first wine we ordered was a Clos de Gat Chardonnay. I don't remember the vintage. I didn't even like it so much. It was okay. It was a little too big and blowsy for me. I was just talking about it with Amy recently, and I said, "Remember we had that Clos de Gat?" And she looked at me like I was crazy. She said, "How do you remember that?" And I, like you — wine experiences remind me of the people, the experience, the time, what was going on. It's kind of a marker.
[68:40] SIMON: The high point of his day isn't the wine. It's the moment before it. Hearing what's for dinner, walking down to the cellar, choosing. And a little grandson who sees him on the stairs and asks for wine. And the first wine he ever drank in Israel, in Jerusalem. He didn't even like it very much. He just remembers it anyway, because of who was at the table.
[69:07] SIMON: You heard me say it before. I don't remember the wines the way I remember the people I drank them with. And Jeff, who has tasted more great wine than almost anyone I know, said the wine is a marker. It tells you where you were, and who you were with, and what was going on in your life.
[69:27] SIMON: I think that's where greatness actually lives. Not only in the bottle, and not only in the story printed on it. In the moments, and the people you share it with.
Closing
[69:41] SIMON: Three episodes ago, I asked a simple question. Were the great wines of yesterday really that great? Here's where I've come out on this.
[69:52] SIMON: Some of them were. A duke, a family of merchants, a few monks on a few good slopes found greatness, and some of it was real. But it was rare. It was tied to a handful of places, and it was at the mercy of every summer. They could find greatness. But they couldn't repeat it.
[70:17] SIMON: Then science came, and the winemaker gained a thousand small decisions. Greatness became something you could reach for on purpose, in more places, more often, even in the middle of the Negev. Something was lost along the way, mostly in the everyday wine. But much, much more was gained.
[70:41] SIMON: And tonight we found the last piece. Some of what we call greatness was never in the bottle at all. It was in the price, and the score, and the name on the label, and in the habit we'd learned in old cellars. It was in a forged bottle that collectors praised for years, and in a Long Island Chardonnay that an expert mistook for a Burgundy. The great illusion isn't that old wines were good. It's believing that the legend on the label is the wine in the glass.
[71:21] SIMON: I promised I'd answer the question I've asked every guest. The greatest wine I've ever had: if it were made again tomorrow, would it still be astonishing to me?
[71:33] SIMON: I've thought about it a great deal, and I keep coming back to the same bottle. The Herzog Chalk Hill Cabernet Sauvignon, from the middle of the 1990s.
[71:46] SIMON: It wasn't my first wine. I cut my Kiddush teeth on Manischewitz, and then eventually on Kedem grape juice. My first real wine pleasure was a sweet one, Craig Winchell's Gan Eden Black Muscat. My first serious dry red was the Baron Rothschild 1986. And for years in New York, the Herzog Napa Valley Cabernet Reserve was the wine I could count on. When I saw it on a list, I knew dinner was going to be great.
[72:24] SIMON: But Chalk Hill was different. Every bottle I opened seemed better than the one before. It lit up every dinner it touched. It's the wine that turned me from someone who enjoyed wine into someone who went looking for it. I went from shop to shop and bought whatever I could find.
[72:46] SIMON: Think about where that wine came from. The same family whose Kedem was on my Shabbat table. And it arrived in exactly the years Jeff told us about, when kosher wine was going from the strangest tasting he'd ever been to, to scores in the nineties in Wine Spectator. Without knowing it, I was drinking the moment kosher wine's reputation turned.
[73:12] SIMON: So if that wine were poured for me tomorrow, would it still blow me away? Honestly, I don't think it would, the way it did then. And I don't think that would be the wine's fault.
[73:28] SIMON: When I first tasted it, I had never tasted anything like it. Since then, I've tasted thirty years of wines, wines that have gotten better and better. Some of them I helped make. My palate has moved on. The man who opened those bottles was discovering something. You can only discover something once.
[73:51] SIMON: But I have one piece of evidence on the other side. Not long ago, I opened an old Herzog Napa Reserve Cabernet, a bottle signed by Philip Herzog. It was fantastic. Some wines' impressions do last, as Jeff said. And the only way to know is to open it.
[74:13] SIMON: So here's my real answer. I wouldn't want the wine back. I'd want the dinner back. The table, and the young man who was just finding out what wine could be. That's what made it great. The bottle was only where it happened.
[74:30] SIMON: There's a blessing in our tradition that I love. When a second wine comes to the table during a meal, and others are sharing it with you, we add the blessing HaTov v'HaMeitiv: Blessed is the One who is good, and does good. You'll find it discussed in tractate Berachot.
[74:51] SIMON: Two things about that blessing have stayed with me all through this series. It's a blessing over wine shared with others. Alone, you don't say it. It belongs to the people at the table, exactly where Jeff told us the memory lives. And like every blessing, you say it before you taste. Before you know if the wine will live up to its label, its price, or its score. Gratitude first. The verdict, if it matters at all, comes later.
[75:25] SIMON: So here's what I'd like you to do this week. Pour two wines for friends, in bags, or in a decanter, or with the labels turned away. One you think of as special, and one you don't. Don't tell anyone which is which. Taste, talk, and only then take off the bags. You may be surprised. You may not. Either way, you'll have tasted the wine and not the story. And then open a bottle you've been saving for the right moment. Not because it's ready. Because the people are.
[76:02] SIMON: My thanks to Jeff Morgan of Covenant, who has sat on both sides of the label and was generous enough to tell us what he saw from each. And thank you for walking through this whole series with me.
[76:16] SIMON: The Great Wine Illusion was never really about old wine or new wine. It was about how we taste. So taste generously, taste honestly, and say the blessing before you judge. L'chaim.
Outro
[76:41] SIMON: This is Simon Jacob again, your host of this episode of The Kosher Terroir. Please subscribe via your podcast provider, to be informed of our new episodes as they are released. If you are new to The Kosher Terroir, please check out our many past episodes.